10 Contested Images of 2012

Remember that little video campaign called #Kony2012? Yeah, we wish we could forget too. Few videos have reached the magnitude of pestilence that the non-profit Invisible Children’s video achieved this year. By transforming a complex regional crisis involving the Lord’s Resistance Army into a simple, manufactured (and in some ways factually false) narrative about the forces of good and evil, Jason Russell and his team at Invisible Children mobilized overeager teenagers like never before. Sharing the Kony 2012 video on Facebook and Twitter became akin to saving vulnerable African children from certain abduction. Activism had never been so easy. Amidst the cauldron of outrage, shock and disappointment stirred by the Kony 2012 video, Glenna Gordon released the photo above that further damaged the efforts of Russell and Co. to appear serious and altruistic. Invisible Children tried to embrace the image, calling it a joke, but the damage was done. The furor caused by the video mutated into deeper scrutiny and critical backlash, exposing IC’s ties to evangelical Christian organizations and leading the heroic Russell to have his infamous breakdown.

In April, Swedish artist Makode Linde decided to bake a cake for an exhibition commemorating the 75th anniversary of the Swedish Artists’ National Organization. Linde, however, neglected to mention to the exhibition’s organizers that his gollywog-style cake, crafted in the shape of a black body would be alive (with Linde himself inside it). As soon as the exhibition’s guest of honor, Swedish Culture Minister Lena Adelsohn Liljeroth, cut into the cake it began to wail loudly. Finding humor in the cake’s pained cries, the Culture Minister proceeded to feed the cake to itself, leading to this image by Marianne Lindberg De Geer.

Few if any of the event’s guests seemed to be troubled by the writhing, shrieking cake and on the contrary many reveled in cutting slices for themselves. The Minister was soon accused of racial insensitivity by the National Afro-Swedish Association, which called for her resignation. An interview with Makode Linde later revealed that the cake was intended to be part of his “Afromantics” series on black identity and cultural representation in Sweden and not a trap intended solely for the Minister. Whatever the artist’s intention was, Lindberg De Geer’s image bears testimony to that fact that sometimes an artwork can acquire greater social resonance than its creator ever intended.

Tension between mine workers, their employers and unions boiled over in South Africa this August as police were called in to quell miners striking against low wages and poor working conditions in a mine in Marikana owned by the London-based firm Lonmin. Toyi-toying for better living and working conditions is not uncommon in South Africa, but this time, when the dust settled, 34 miners lay dead, ridden with bullets. Many in South Africa were outraged at the horror of the police officers’ actions, many blamed the recklessness of the miners, many more barely batted an eyelid. The violence at Marikana presented South Africans with an opportunity to confront issues of lingering economic injustice, yet instead of embracing dialogue, the South African government thought it prudent to charge miners arrested in the unrest with the murder of their comrades.

With few lessons learned from the tragedy at Marikana, black economic empowerment business tycoon and Lonmin board member, Cyril Ramaphosa, was elected to the position of Vice President of the governing ANC at the party’s recent conference in Mangaung. Was Ramaphosa’s connection to the deaths of the miners not a red flag? Without meaningful efforts to address South Africa’s woefully unequal wealth distribution, sadly, there could be more Marikanas to come. (Photo by Siphiwe Sibeko.)

On January 1st 2012, the Nigerian government wished its citizens a happy new year by eliminating a subsidy on fuel prices dubbed “unsustainable” by the Governor of the Nigerian Central Bank, Sanusi Lamido Sanusi. The subsidy’s removal, favored by Nigerian president Goodluck Jonathan and Finance Minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, caused fuel prices to jump by 120% practically overnight and led to increases in the cost of other essential goods. Fed up with the high cost of fuel in Africa’s largest oil producer and disillusioned with fiscal policy favoring elites, Nigerian citizens staged massive protests and strikes across the country. Angry protesters demanded a reinstatement of the subsidy and an end to corruption and financial mismanagement on the part of the Nigerian government. After two weeks of widespread protest, which became known as Occupy Nigeria, the Nigerian Government realized its maladroit political manoeuvring and reinstated the subsidy.

As a postscript — In April 2012 American Jim Kim beat out Nigerian Finance Minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala in the contest for the World Bank presidency. Some Nigerians were dismayed not by Kim’s victory, but because Okonjo-Iweala’s defeat meant she would continue to be in a position to implement fiscal policy that could be damaging to the lives of Nigerian citizens. (Photo by Akintunde Akinleye.)

In 2012, the Summer Olympics came to London. And while the Americans and the Chinese raced to the top of the medal tables, the British hosts struggled to win major events on their home turf. Enter Mo Farah, a Brit of Somali heritage, who represented Great Britain’s greatest hope to take gold in the high profile track races. With magical endurance and speed to match, Farah walked the walk and delivered gold medals in the 5,000 and 10,000-meter races to a roaring home audience. For this moment, the British people rejoiced in the victory they shared with Farah.

Yet this revelry ignored the questioning of identities that African immigrants routinely endure in British society. Following the events, renowned Somali author Nuruddin Farah was quoted as saying, “I wish [Mo Farah] were wholly ours; that we, Somalis had invested in him and given him all that which have made him a winner.” Does Mo’s victory mean the British are ready to embrace Mo Farah along with immigrants and their descendants as wholly British? What of those who cannot run so fast? (Photo by Olivier Morin.)

Besides its unabashed attacks on Palestinian civilians, the state of Israel severely tightened its immigration policies in 2012, deporting hundreds of African immigrants (like the man in the photo below), threatening to repatriate thousands more and coercing female Ethiopian immigrants in particular to accept birth control injections. In comments laden with white supremacist rhetoric, Prime Minister Netanyahu even went as far as calling African immigrants living in Israel “infiltrators”.

Israeli immigration officers escort an African migrant in south Tel AvivMany immigrants of African origin have lived in Israel for many years, some seeking greater economic opportunity and others fleeing from conflict. More than a few African immigrants subscribe to Jewish beliefs themselves, though perhaps even the converts don’t fit into the constructed vision of what Jewish people are supposed to be. But hey, at least European Jews have never migrated to other countries in search of refuge and economic prosperity. Oh, wait. (Photo by Baz Ratner.)

The illustrious life of South African President Jacob Zuma has been so inspiring to his citizens, that in 2012 Zuma was the muse for a provocative painting by artist Brett Murray. The piece in question, titled “The Spear”, depicted Zuma in a pose that mimicked propaganda images of Lenin in the Soviet Union, though with Zuma’s penis exposed. “The Spear,” along with other works in Murray’s exhibition (called Hail to the Thief II), represented a pessimistic commentary on governance under the African National Congress while portraying Zuma’s controversial lifestyle rooted in Zulu cultural tradition as misogynistic.

As the South African public debated the freedom of expression, two men entered that exhibition’s gallery and defaced the painting (the unequal treatment of the two defacers, one black, one white, by gallery security is another issue entirely). To the dismay of the Zuma camp, this act only further elevated the portrait’s notoriety in the annals of South African art history. (Photo by Jerome Delay.)

After a few years of dithering, the UN’s science and cultural organization UNESCO finally embraced the abandonment of its dignity by awarding a science prize sponsored by the unscrupulous president of Equatorial Guinea, Teodoro Obiang Nguema Mbasogo. It mattered not that the longest serving president in Africa, in power since 1979, has been accused of corruption and human rights violations of epic proportions. Nor did it matter that his son Teodoro Nguema Obiang Mangue aka Teodorín, Minister of Agriculture and Forestry in his father’s government, has somehow amassed a fortune that has afforded him multi-million dollar estates in California and Paris on a modest government salary. The young Obiang’s questionable finances have led authorities in France to issue a warrant for his arrest and seize his $100 million dollar French estate (which had a $2 million wine collection).

Based on the smile on UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon’s face in the photo (by Eskinder Debebe) and the dissatisfaction on that of the elder Obiang, perhaps the dignity of the UN wasn’t worth as much as it was sold for.

Just prior to presidential elections scheduled in Mali for April, soldiers staged a coup against the government of President Amadou Toumani Touré. Once in control of Bamako, the soldiers, led by Captain Amadou Sanogo, cited failure by the Touré regime to adequately equip them to confront the attacks by nomadic Touareg rebels plaguing the north of the country as their reason for taking power. Exploiting the moment of political chaos in Bamako, the nomadic Touareg rebel groups began seizing greater expanses of land until they had carved the country in two. This new territory, which included the city of Timbuktu, was to be called Azawad. Members of the National Movement for the Liberation of Azawad wave the new territory’s flag in the image (by Jemal Oumar) below.

Since the creation of Azawad, non-Touareg ethnic groups have fled the region as pro-Azawad Islamist forces have attacked dissenters, banned non-Islamic music and destroyed mausoleums containing historically valuable, centuries-old texts. The Touaregs claim Azawad as their traditional pastoral grazing lands, yet other ethnic groups contest that they have lived there for generations. Regional body ECOWAS and the UN have threatened military intervention to reunify the country, yet so far no troops have been mobilized. How will the disputed nation of Azawad fare in 2013?

The battle for LGBT rights continued in Uganda in 2012, where the legislators vowed to pass a law criminalizing homosexuality with severe jail time. Supporters of the legislation maintain their claim that homosexuality is a foreign import that is contrary to “African tradition,” while critics of the bill have questioned just how the sexual orientation of gay Ugandans somehow prevents them from being African. Despite the threatening environment, brave Ugandans turned out for a gay pride rally that took place in August.

Meanwhile, legislators have promised that the anti-gay bill has a 99% chance of passing. (Photo by David Robinson.)

21 thoughts on “10 Contested Images of 2012

  1. I still don’t understand why the golliwog cake was a big story, and reading through the artistic interpretations of it on this site hasn’t helped at all. Here’s how I see it: It was an awkward moment, and people in such an awkward position are inclined to laugh. Because it’s an art thing, I think many people who didn’t “get” the art would feel hesitant to criticize it and risk looking uninformed or having no artistic sense. Too many people read more into the situation than was warranted; it was an awkward moment, and a really weird piece of art. Also, it was cake, and who in their right mind turns down a piece of cake?

    • You must be non-female, non-African and non-sympathetic to make such a callous argument. Barring the above, “common sense” alone should tell you that it was wrong. “Art” cannot be used an excuse for recklessness, if anything this only diminshes it.

  2. Africas and Africa has been used by the west for too long. Western leadership has ganged up to ensure that Africa never develops because if it doea achieve economic independence, the west is bound to sink. If Africa ceases to export raw materials, the value will be added to the raw materials and jobs created in Africa. Africans are bound to emmigrate to the west to seek better opportunities as a result. With the rise of xenophobia in the west and with more africans being exposed to the truth of the world political and economic dynamics, I see in the near future a change as more African countries are opening up to the East for trade and technology. The time for Westerners to start emmigration to Africa is near.

  3. What nonsense about London 2012: ‘the British hosts struggled to win major events on their home turf.’ I think you’ll find that we finished third in the medals table and the British public consider it to have been a massive success. As for African identities in British culture? Britain is a melting pot with a high level of integration for people with all sorts of backgrounds; the idea that there are a few ‘pure breds’ still trying to decide whether Africans are worthy of being considered British is nonsense. I would argue there is more discrimination and difficulty in finding a national identity in Africa itself (I live in Uganda). Mo Farah did not win his British identity… also please note the difference in the way he, and other people of African descent, is treated in the UK as opposed to the US.

    • too right, we did good us Brits and the comment in the piece is not true, and the nation was less inclined to wheel out racist slurs for a good few weeks afterwards, so success!!!

      Not sure why this site us getting an awful lot of negative comments and as for being anti christian and anti semite,, well, I have to ask people, just because someone doesn’t agree with you, surely that doesn’t give them less right to be heard, does it? So let a person speak who is shocked at the behaviours of those with a religious bent in their motivation, it’s not sensible to be paranoid over those who differ in opinion.

    • I dislike the term – melting pot since it actually doesn’t spell out – hey, feel free to be who you are and we’ll accept you. Melting pot is more like – we’re one big happy family – of different races, religions, etc… but in order for you to be a part of us, you must become like us.

      Anyways, It seems like you’re a person of privilege who assumes that everyone, regardless of race, is treated/seen as “British.” Perhaps, you should talk to immigrants – see how they’re treated. I’m pretty sure the answer you’ll get will only reiterate what the author wrote.

  4. Just reading your website for the first time, I see you are virulent anti-Christian bigots and anti-semitic too. I suspect many of those obsessed with ‘helping’ Africa are the same.

    • sorry where do you get this idea from? And why should people who wish to help others be treated by you this way? And truly well meaning people do not need a higher body to worship actually they just do good because it is in their nature so back off

  5. I am thoroughly confused as to how those supporting Palestine’s interests ignore the constant and indiscriminate shelling of Siderot, attacks targeted solely on citizens, and the regional rhetoric which declares no recognition for Israel and an unyielding aim of its destruction. How is it possible to paint Israel as the aggressors?

  6. Interesting pictures, but the weirdly tangential commentary was too offensive for me to get through the whole piece. Invisible Children – nice picture capturing the weird story of a charitable organization that seemed so good until it turned so bad, but why on earth is this important: “exposing IC’s ties to evangelical Christian organizations”? Seems like something no one would care about unless they think such organizations are inherently evil, which most rational people would disagree with and at any rate is just a tangent.

    Agree with previous commenter. Absurd to call Brits out as racist for cheering for a Somali-Brit (I don’t know the proper terminology) who emigrated to the UK and has been wildly successful. “Yet this revelry ignored the questioning of identities that African immigrants routinely endure in British society. . . . What of those who cannot run so fast?” Brits are racist, because … well they aren’t being racist here, but I think they’re racist anyway … so, uh, yeah, Brits are racist. Absurd.

    Paragraph on Israel is awful.

    But hey! Nice pictures!

  7. Yeah, I too noticed the not-so-subtle Christophobia and anti-Semitism on this site. Completely destroys any hint of credibility the site might otherwise have.

  8. Thee are Ethiopians who are Jewish from a long time ago and there are Africans who have also gone to Israel. Your simplistic post seems more intent upon belittling Israel than making a distinction that ought to have been made.

  9. “But hey, at least European Jews have never migrated to other countries in search of refuge and economic prosperity. Oh, wait.”

    What does that mean? Does it mean that you can be happy if European Jews haven’t migrated in other countries? I hope that’s not the intention, because if it was it would be highly racist and ignorant. First: You cannot link Israel’s policy to European Jews. I know many European Jews opposing ocupataion etc and plus, Israel’s policy is decided by various Jewish groups. Second: European Jews are neither better nor worse citizens than others, having a wide range of political views and behaviours. For example, South African Jews of European origin represent various views and some of them are critical of Israel’s policy.

    • No… The tongue-in-check comment points out the fact that European Jews left Europe in the wake of the holocaust to seek refuge in what would become Israel. And now, Israel is ironically cracking down on immigrants who are fleeing persecution or violence in their own countries.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s