Photography. The Jews of Morocco

Aaron Elkaim is a documentary photographer based in Toronto. He studied Film and Cultural anthropology before deciding to pursue photography. With four other Canadian photographers, he founded the Boreal Collective. His photo-essay “Exodus,” which won second prize in the 2010 Viewbook Photostory documentary competition, explores the remains of the Jewish communities in Morocco. He documents personal and familial narratives, archival and architectural remains of Jewish communities in modern-day Morocco. The accompanying notes mention that the Jewish community was founded over two thousand years ago, prospered for centuries, and grew to occupy a proud place within Moroccan national identity.

Could you explain how you discovered this history, and outline the motivations behind your decision to engage with it?

I discovered this history while researching my own family history. My father was born in Marrakech and immigrated to Canada in the 1960’s with most of his family. I was primarily raised with my mother, and didn’t have much frame of reference to my Moroccan Jewish ancestry. My desire to learn more is what led me to my research.

Initially I was interested in the fact that the community there seemed to be disappearing. In my mind I though about an old Jewish culture and community that was about to disappear, and thought that for this reason it was important to go there and document it before it was gone. In hindsight this approach would have been very one-dimensional … that romantic ideal I was visualizing was mostly already gone and replaced by the modern world.

It took me some time before I began to see what the story would eventually become, about the positive history that existed between the Muslim and Jewish cultures in Morocco. The more I explored and the more I learned I began to see how this history did not seem to fit into the modern day reality of Muslim and Jewish relations that is presented in the mainstream. For me this history was a shining light in an otherwise dark world, this is what became my motivation.

The images are strikingly varied, recording religious and social ritual, personal conversations, individual portraits, cataloguing objects and describing landscapes. Could you explain how this project was organised, and how the images relate to your trip(s) to Morocco?

This project takes place over two separate trips. The first trip was one month in 2009 with my father and was mostly exploratory. I had ideas floating around before I got there, but only once I was there was I confronted with the seeds of the story. Once back home in Canada I began to think about how I would further develop the story on my return … When I returned the next year I gave myself three months to work. I knew I wanted to explore old sites and photograph Muslim guardians of Jewish sites; I also wanted to document the remaining community in their daily life and rituals. Visiting sites was the easy part as I could find out where they were and simply go there. When I work I try to always follow my gut. I try to meet as many people I can and never try to force pictures out of my encounters, but always try to be ready for when the picture reveals itself to me.

For the final organization of the work, I do most of that in the edit. Certain images that I may have thought would be essential to the story when captured are often discarded in the edit. When I photograph I am simply collecting fragments of the story, pieces of the puzzle. The edit is putting those pieces together and creating the final image. I do photograph with a rough plan and when the photos stop coming I return to that plan, but I am usually seeing where the path leads me rather than trying to pre-construct too much.

You quote the words of King Mohammed V, asserting against the wishes of fascist Germany, that “We have no Jews in Morocco, only Moroccan citizens.” Yet you note that the star of David was removed from the flag due to a request from an anti-semitic French government. One way in which you explore the complex relationships between Morocco, Europe and the Jewish diaspora is through attention to the guardians of the Jewish heritage in Morocco, who are mostly not Jewish. Some of these images describe tensions which mostly arise, it seemed, due to economic relations. Could you tell us a little more about your encounters with them?

During my first trip to Morocco I visited the Al Zama Synagogue in Marrakech and met a Muslim lady who lived there. She cooked, cleaned and lived alongside the Jews who were also living at or visiting the synagogue. In many ways they seemed like family and maintained a close and amicable relationship. It was here that I was inspired to focus on the guardians as an aspect of my story. As I moved around the country I found a wide range of different situations these guardians were in. Financially speaking I found that most of these guardians were not paid directly by any Jewish Organization but received donations from visitors. Some lived in very remote areas where visitors were rare, and likewise donations were sparse. Each guardian had their own personal history with the Jewish people. Some of these people had close relations with the Jewish community before they had left and were therefore entrusted to care for the sites after the last Jews left. Often it would be the children who had taken over after their parent, the previous guardian, had passed on. Overall there was a sense of admiration for the Jewish community whom they had lived alongside.

In one instance a man who had been guardian of a cemetery living on site raising animals with his family since 1955 was going to be evicted by the Jewish community who wanted to develop the land where they lived. His son had ill feelings towards the Jewish community, believing his father had given them his life and they had given nothing back in return. The father, on the other hand, seemed to remember the Jews he once lived alongside with such reverence that he held no ill feeling towards them and seemed to maintain a sense of pride for the work he had done. Another man I had met in Ksar el-Kebir had immense pride for his job of guarding a cemetery and a Jewish saint who rested there. This particular saint was quite revered and there were annual pilgrimages to his site that the guardian was always involved with. Often Jewish and Moroccan dignitaries would attend these events and the guardian felt truly appreciated. He also grew up as close friends with some revered members of the Jewish community. At another pilgrimage in Ouazzane the guardian there would sing songs in Hebrew with visiting Jews during their celebrations, it was quite inspirational.

One thing I wonder though is how the younger generation will feel towards the Jews as the older generation who once lived alongside them pass on. Will they fall into the dichotomy of the modern world?

On your website, you suggest it is the aim of photography to “urge the viewer to ask more questions and seek more answers.” Is this project consciously engaging with an existing literature or debate? If so, where and how does this project access a community of viewers?

Yes, I believe it does. It engages with the debate of what it means to be Jewish and the question of homeland. Zionism has framed the Jewish identity through its Biblical and historic connection to Israel and their persecution during the holocaust. Morocco is a place where Jews lived for thousands of years; these Jews formed a unique culture and identity that was shaped by their relationship to the land and their neighbors (Arab, Muslim and Berber). They were also protected during the holocaust by their Muslim King.

Currently, the overriding narrative in the Middle East concerns Palestine and Israel. This narrative boils down to Muslims against Jews, but when you look at histories such as that of Morocco, we see that, with the black and white approach of simply boiling down identities and histories into “us and them,” we lose all the shades of grey, and it is in these that we find the tones of truth and understanding. That is what I am hoping to reveal and I hope to urge viewers to seek more answers, to find those shades of grey. We all too often stick to one camp or the other (pro/anti), but truth and hope lies in the cracks in-between.

There appears to be an argument made in the series about the potential for multi-faith and multi-ethnic communities to prosper in modern cities and nation states. That is partly why this anthropology seems so optimistic. Against this, however, there is a more recent problem, for the Jewish diaspora in particular, which is the pressure exerted by international geo-politics (Zionism; Israel) on local community relations. Is this part of an ongoing inquiry in your work?

I am really not trying to make any sort of an argument. With my work I hope to share my perspective and a story, the viewers will hopefully come to their own conclusions. The history of Morocco is not the modern world; today things are very different in regards to international power struggles, ideologies, and propagandas. I do however try to be idealistic and search for hope that the world can change for the better, that humans are capable of understanding one another and finding ways of working and living together. I believe this is seen in Morocco and its history, yet I am not pretending that the history there was perfect and problem free, the important thing is that it worked.

For the second part of your question, there is indeed a pressure exerted on the diaspora Jewish communities by international geo-politics, and it is these communities whom I hope are inspired by this story to look deeper at the histories rather than be persuaded by propaganda and nationalistic or faith based loyalties.

* Elkaim’s work has been published in a number of on-line publications and blogs and has also been exhibited at multiple international photography festivals. It will also be shown in a solo show at the Pikto Gallery in Toronto during the 2012 Contact Photography Festival.

13 thoughts on “Photography. The Jews of Morocco

    • One of many who left in the 50s 60s and 70s… However, the Moroccan Jewish Community was never forced out of Morocco, quite the contrary. The creators of the new Jewish state incited Jews all over the world to come to Israel promising them land, peace, and fortune… we know today that all this didnt go to plan. Most of the moroccan jews are now either in France, in the USA, or in Israel. Those who remained form a thriving jewish community which although small in size, remains important both in its political influence and economic impact. The historical presence of the jewish community is even inshrined in the new Moroccan constitution and the relationship between the different ethnic minorities constituting the moroccan diaspora remains peaceful as it has been throughout Moroccan history.

      • Well Ish, there are truth and untruth, but being a Jew in Morocco has never been easy.
        Short of the French coming and bringing some concepts of human rights, the Jews were essentially overtaxed and segregated even limited in the dress code…
        When the country became independent, various campaigns of boycott against them , their businesses when they had one, and finally the distinct discrimination even expressed in the language : lhihoudy hashek et the individual violence like the screams of young arab boys stoning everyday to the point of a bloody face the poor jew named Tfaha d’Spagna who was an elderly poor and afraid to be lynched myself … I could not intervene when only 9 years old.. It is nice to lie to oneself but America and Israel had little to do with my desire to leave… Just finding a place where my quality of Jew was not my first and only identity to whomever I met…

      • Omg you guys. His family left because they were in a really bad situation i didn’t say EVERY SINGLE ONE was. ONE PERSON left because they were beat up. And don’t even try to tell me he is lying. Sometimes people get beat up you guys and they don’t enjoy it. Is that okay with you?

      • i would love to know how many of you were actually a jew in morocco about 60 years ago and experienced life first hand that you are just discrediting one actual account. It was literally just one story of one family. Don’t get your panties in a bunch

  1. Oh well he has a very different memeory of why his family left in the late 40’s, he has a very negative view of muslims because of it (not that I’m saying that’s good). They did leave I think ultimatley because of Israel, but also because of conflict. It was a long hard road to get to Israel, he ended up seperate from his parents for a year or so in france and i think found them again in Israel.

  2. I am a Muslim who studied in a Jewish School in Morocco. I was also raised with many Jews around me in Morocco. The Jews in Morocco have attained very high levels in the government over the centuries, something that did not happen in very many countries.

    The Moroccan Jews are and were conscientious people who formed part of the Moroccan culture. Those who continue to live here are linked to the higher political, economic and social structures.

    There are isolated non-disastrous incidents, but that is the exception NOT the rule. Those people who have used derogatory words are NOT considered Moroccans.

    Personally, I do NOT like to make a distinction between Muslim and Moroccan Jews. We have grown together and built a country together over the centuries in a spirit of partnership.

  3. Ben ,
    I like your approch on the subject. I left Morocco at the age of 14 just after the 67 war. Of course I always missed Casalanca and Morocco, and I cannot denied the felling of detortion that my heart felt and the saddness that went with me for many monthes after I left. My parents stayed behind and it was one of the hardest think that could happen to a youg man of that age.
    Today, after 45 years leaving in Israel and, of course having visited Morocco, this time as a tourist and having seen much more of it, and not just Casablanca, I might perhaps be able to say few things about it.
    Let me first start by saying that if all muslims were like the morocan people, I beleive that peace, tolerance and brotherhood would reign in our part of the world. Mutual influence and enrichment could make our peoples florish and prosper.
    Also, there is no reason on earth why Jewish people would not have there own piece of homeland just like eveyone else.
    The perfect merging of jewish people in Morocco that was since 538 years BJC, is something that should be learned in Universities around the world. They settle down, meanly in the south and the Atlas.To remind you, Morocco had this jewish presence and influence long before Islam came there.
    I wish there was some studies wich could tell us more about these times. But as it seems to be they were received and absorbed with courtesie and equality.
    I think that some disconfort started to be felt when Jamal Abdul Nasser from Egypt visited in the 60th and planted some heathred and the hearts of young muslim moroccans. Yes we felt a change in the air and the general athmosfer in the streets. Nothing rom the governement of the official authoroties. Yes I was beatten and some of my friends as well. But frankly we related that to “une band the voyoux” and nothing more.
    On the other hand the felling of leaving in your own country was very appeling, and we knew what were the challenges and difficulties we were facing ahead.
    Nevertheless we, moroccan jewery are very proud of our backroud and remain very attached
    to our native country. No one in Morocco should feel guilty, and yes we were never forced to leave. This is just the course of history and we toguether with our brothers in morocco should and must show the other that it can be different, as it was for so many decades.
    Daniel Perez

  4. This is a very interesting and important story to document. I am currently taking a class on Human Rights: Jews in the Arab World, and will focus on Moroccan Jews for a project. Do any of you happen to know a memoir or a book written by a Moroccan Jew about their experience in the 1900’s? I am very interested in learning more about this untold story. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s