We are all Andries Tatane

By An Anonymous Reader
South Africa is far from what Tunisia was like pre-revolution (for one it is not governed by a one-party police state; or it does not conducts mass arrests of its opponents; and if you insult the president you don’t get tortured and jailed indefinitely), but the parallels of small-town cops beating to death a South Africa Everyman because he was angry with poor or non-existent service delivery (water, electricity, roads, housing) are eerily reminiscent of what happened to a certain fruit vendor in southern Tunisia. (Here‘s video footage from South African TV news of the murder.)

But if you asked someone in Meqheleng where Andries Tatane was murdered (yes, I did look up the largest township in Ficksburg in the Free State Province) whether they are as frustrated as your typical Tunisian circa 2010, I wonder what they would reply?

Would the ANC’s proper electoral mandate and liberation credentials outweigh the impression that those in power–personified by President Jacob Zuma, and his Ministers or ANC leaders like Tokyo Sexwale, Sicelo Shiceka, and Siphiwe Nyanda, etcetera–are amassing wealth and governing just like Hosni Mubarak and Ben Ali?

My hunch is a few years from now the residents of Meqheleng or any of the townships or squatter settlements won’t care how legitimate the ruling party’s mandate is: poor service delivery is poor service delivery.

You know at least for now in further Tunisia parallels the people of Ficksburg have ratcheted things up a bit.

Which leads me this:

Does that 18-year old in Meqheleng know the basic dynamics of what is happening in North Africa or the Middle East? Are vernacular radio and local papers giving the “Arab spring” coverage, at least to the point that that 18-year old realizes how crap Mubarak was and, closer to home, how dismissive the ANC leadership has been to their demands the last 17 years, basically the span of his or her entire lifespan?

Trevor Manuel, the former finance minister, said in the aftermath of the Paris riots that Cape Town (see our previous posts on that city) is treading water. And Moeletsi Mbeki, Maoist brother of Thabo, has drawn a depressing picture for the country following the events in Tunis.

We shouldn’t be surprised when in the absence of meaningful political representation and mediation, the atrophy of social change, the lack of redistribution of wealth from white to black, and in a context of socially acceptable and government sanctioned accumulation through nepotism, cronyism, and political-connectedness, the structural violence of South African life finds vivid and widespread expression.

“Service delivery” protests (a misnomer if there ever was one), or what passes as xenophobic, domestic, interpersonal violence, wanton brutality on the part of security apparatus, all these are all symptoms of the greater malaise.

6 thoughts on “We are all Andries Tatane

  1. Somebody does not like South Africa joining the BRIC group.

    Those who whine about ANC, why now? Why not 15 years ago when cake was redistributed?

  2. the comparison with tunisia
    isnt it a bit over the top
    public service delivery is the pain in the … the world over
    lets not get too excited
    rather lets deal with a problem as it relates to us
    each country has its own burdens
    aren’t the police in custody now and facing charges
    what we need to be commenting on is the service delivery or lack of
    rememba how Chris Hani’s death propelled us into the elections
    it was a case of NOW not later we are going to the polls
    i would rather we use this to push for change
    instead of sitting behind our social networks
    using big words to comment and comment and complain
    shouldnt we [you included] be organising/participating/rallying
    another demonstration and another and another
    for service delivery until something moves
    afterall this is what Andries Tatane fought and died for
    that said, condolences to his fam

  3. Andries Tatane was shot even though he had already been contained by the police. It is a completely unacceptable, repugnant and coward act of the government toward its people. The president himself should resign; something must be done to give South Africa back to its people. As a foreign spectator the shooting images let me down and horrified. God bless Andries Tatane’s soul and his family.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s